Herbal Medicine vs. Allopathic Medicine
Have you ever taken a look at what was growing around you outside your door? Did you know that many of the plants growing along the edge of your driveway, or even on your lawn, have medicinal value? Herbal medicine has been around for thousands of years. Cultures on every continent have passed down empirical knowledge regarding the use of plants and trees as medicine. It has only been in the last 200 years or so that its use has been eclipsed by the promise of modern medicine.
Taking a more natural approach to medicine requires you to slow down, and listen to the signals your body is giving you. It is a holistic approach, treating the whole person, not just the symptoms (as allopathy does). Herbal medicine utilizes whole parts of the plant (including leaves, flowers, roots, and bark) in teas, tinctures and oils. The active components of plants have a synergistic effect, supportively nourishing the body. Along with the medicinal affects, some of plants also confer nutritional benefits as well: nettles are a good source of iron, and rose hips contain vitamin C. In allopathic medicine, one chemical has been separated from the whole and then magnified to proportions that could never be recreated in nature.
The debate between herbal medicine and allopathic medicine is controversial. I am not trying to say that I don’t believe in modern allopathic medicine- if I fall and break something, I will go to a hospital for treatment, the same goes with most any acute trauma. But it doesn’t need to be the answer for everything. Superficial burns can be treated with aloe, honey, and/or a poultice of lavender and calendula flowers. A blend of peppermint, hyssop, yarrow, and elder flowers has been used for centuries as a cold remedy. Bee stings can be treated with a paste made from plantain leaves.
One of the biggest benefits of herbal medicine, in my opinion, is that you know exactly what you are being treated with; this is especially true if you grew or harvested it yourself. I just don’t like the idea of taking a little white pill that is supposed to make everything better. I see the arsenal of medicines that my parents are taking; one pill for blood pressure, one for pain, one to relieve the swelling caused by the other pill, and so on and so on. After a while, people become utterly chained to their medication, never thinking that there might be another option.
*It should also be noted that just because herbs are natural, it doesn’t mean they are all safe. Some should never be taken during pregnancy, others can cause side effects if used improperly. All natural medicines should be used with respect and caution.
Here is a good article if you are interested in more information about this topic: http://www.umm.edu/altmed/articles/herbal-medicine-000351.htm
Definitions:
Allopathic medicine: allos meaning opposite and path meaning disease. Dorland's Illustrated Medical Dictionary also defines it as a "term applied to that system of therapeutics in which diseases are treated by producing a condition incompatible with or antagonistic to the condition to be cured or alleviated.”
(http://www.bio-medicine.org/medicine-definition/Allopathic_medicine/)
Herbal Medicine: Herbal medicine is the art and science of using herbs for promoting health and preventing and treating illness. It has persisted as the world's primary form of medicine since the beginning of time, with a written history more than 5000 years old. While the use of herbs in America has been overshadowed by dependence on modern medications the last 100 years, 75% of the world's population still rely primarily upon traditional healing practices, most of which is herbal medicine.
(http://www.americanherbalistsguild.com/fundamentals)
I hear a lot about heral medacine, but I would never see myself using it. I say that because I cant grasp the concept of the plant right outside my door can help me. I am just so use to allopathic medacine. I think the point can be made that allopathic medacine can be abused while herbal medacine not so much. I dont think we will ever get to the point where America is leaning on herbal medacine as its primary source of help. People dont like change. With some education perhaps there could be some small changes.
ReplyDeleteJulie,
ReplyDeleteNice job. What questions do you have for your classmates to ponder in relation to the information you have presented?
Denise
PS As camp nurse, I used plantain and/or mud packs on insect stings and reactions and the kids thought it was great!
RE:Questions.
ReplyDeleteWhat kind of impact is the rising cost of healthcare having on our society?
Is natural medicine (which is not regulated in the same way) a viable alternative?
Great topic! I think that natural medicine that you would find in the woods is a neat thing to try, if you’re at environmental camp. As a safe alternative I feel if falls short of modern medicine. It's interesting and I would probably teach my (non- existent) children about it to get them interested in the environment but if they were hurt and needed care from a bee sting I wouldn’t practice it.That being said, if I was hiking in the woods and needed first aid care as a band-aid til I was able to use modern medicine I would, so education on it is important. - Heather Razin
ReplyDeleteSo, growing your own herbs could provide a less expensive alternative to buying pharmaceuticals? Awesome. Obviously, though, I would be very cautious to find herbalists who are guild members!
ReplyDeleteI wonder, is disposal of herb supplements less harmful than disposal of regular pharmaceuticals?
I believe in herbal medicine having grown up with some of it. I do not believe it will ever replace modern medicine in America unless a dramatic event took place that somehow wiped out all existence of modern technology. I believe every one should know at least a little bit about herbal medicine. There really should be more education regarding the benefits of herbal medicines. Disposal of herbal medicines is practically natural process because it is plants based, to the best of my knowledge.
ReplyDeleteWe definitely live in a pill popping society where we expect pharmaceuticals to cure everything. Half the time people don't even question whether or not what they are taking is actually helping them or is dangerous because they don't see prescriptions or OTC pills as drugs. The health care industry is pretty much broken so herbal medicine is most likely going to boom in the future. However just because its natural doesn't make it necessarily a great option either. I remember ma huang and ephedra for weight loss a couple of years ago being one such example. It ultimately comes down to personal responsibility and research to see which one works for you.
ReplyDeleteThis is a great blog, and makes for a great debate! I am very ambivalent when it comes to Herbal medicine because of the unknown ramifications of using them. Although there are of course side effects when it comes to pharmaceuticals, we at least know what the predominant amount of them are going to be because of the extensive testing that had to be conducted before they could be distributed. In regards to herbal remedies, as I have said in a past blog; they have not been approved by the F.D.A. because they are in the organic category in which the F.D.A has no jurisdiction. Herbal remedies kind of fall into that "take at your own risk" area and I for one don’t want to risk it. I would also think that your chances of an allergic or hypersensitive reaction are higher when you don’t have some one screening you for allergies and if some one were to react like this modern medicine would be the thing that takes care of it. Also, for the record; all antimicrobials, antifungals, and vaccines are of natural origin and with out them we would be in pretty sad shape. It is a shame that these things have been abused to the point where they are becoming ineffective but they are still our primary weapon against these transients.
ReplyDeleteI agree with the majority of you regarding the fact that Herbal remedies aren't regulated by the F.D.A. at this time (in this country at least). It is also true that most people do not know enough about the topic to make their own remedies. Currently, Europe (Germany in particular) has been far more proactive regarding this topic; they regulate it and some remedies are even covered by health insurance.
ReplyDeleteIt is not a topic to be taken lightly; it takes longer to become a proper Herbalist than it does to become a doctor. You have to know where to find credible information, and who to talk to. But it does have merit for those who are willing to take the time to learn.
This was a very interesting blog, nice job! I have always wondered and wanted to try doing more natural ways of dealing with my illnesses. I just recently had a fever for a few days and wound up taking a lot of medicine that I felt bad about taking, and was actually just thinking I wanted to find some other alternative to taking these medicines. Although I feel as if it is a subject where you really need to know what your doing in order to know what to make, and how much to take of it. It would be really interesting to see herbal remedies used in the health feild, however I would want to have confidence that there has been a lot of studying and learning about all the side effects before I would be able to really trust a doctor when they tell me to eat some plant.
ReplyDeleteThis is a very interesting blog! The first thing that came to my mind after reading this were the effects that natural medicine practices could potentially have on our current health care crisis/dilemma. Promoting these practices and educating people about ways to help with insect bites, burns, ect. could save tax payers and insurance companies a great deal of money. A lot of people jump to go to the Doctor's office for every minor problem which is a waste of time and money.
ReplyDeleteOn the other side, the fact that herbal rememdies aren't really approved by the FDA could cause a major conflict. I found it interesting that it takes longer to become an Herbalist compared to a more traditional Osteopathic Doctor or MD. I do believe that certain herbal rememdies could be very beneficial to our society and that this is a topic that the FDA should potentionally look into. In our economy today we need to be looking a new direction and promote change. I'm not saying that someone should stop going to a traditional Doctor and start seeing an Herbalist, but now days people turn to a pill to cure everything which I don't believe is the answer.-Christine Chambers
Hey Julie!
ReplyDeleteI loved your blog! One of my Aunts who graduated from umf in Community health has saved her life by growing her own herbs. She has had a long line of different illnesses. In the last several months I have been doing a little of my own research on it and have fallen in love with the whole concept. I have even gotten my parents to start planning for the garden for this summer.
All through my life I would get the average cold ten times worse than the average person and docotors just kept trying different things saying that it was just asthma. As a little child I would refuse to take medicane I dont like how it has made me feel. When we got a new chair we found years of pills that I would hide in the chair. Last year I desided that I wanted a grown up doctor so I switched to a women that is more holistic. She tested me for food allergies. I turned out that I was allegic to a ton of foods that I eat everyday. It was a hard task changing my eating patterns but I have been able to stregthan my immune syastem and have not gotten sick nearly as much.
I really liked reading this blog; you did a really great job! I have always heard that the amount of damage that aspirin like medicine does to your stomach is worse than the benefits you get from it. I try not to take Aleve and aspirin that much now. Instead I try to drink water for a headache or sleep. I really feel that most of the time it can be fixed without resorting to meds. But there are definitely times that are necessary for medicine like Julie said if I fall down and break something I’m going to go to the hospital too. I have an aunt that practices Holistic healing and runs a studio that has a lot of customers, they all swear by it.
ReplyDeleteI was wondering if pollution has changed the effects of holistic medicines. Like chemicals and toxins in ground water and soil. Pesticides, bis phenol A, and pharmaceutical drugs, for example, are becoming a permanent part of crops process, even if people grow their own plants. If the structure of these plants changes, how much does that effect how the medicine cures human ailments?
ReplyDeleteMy thinking on not having the FDA aproval does not say a lot about the products. Like what we were talking about in class they have all these policies but do not do anything about it. Money is the key issue here. Who ever is going to make them the most money. It does not matter what they are putting into our product that have been linked with cancers and what nots. I do not personal pay very much attention to what the FDA says. Look at our peanut epidemic.
ReplyDeleteI think this is a great topic, Julie! Well done. I personally am a big believer in looking to more natural medicines if and when I need them. I believe that if we took more time to educate people about how the natural alternatives work, we might find a few more followers. I think that some people may see it as unsafe or not worth the time or effort, or just feel safer having an evaluation/diagnosis/treatment from an MD.
ReplyDeleteAlso many people add marijuana to the natural medicine group, which comes loaded with its own stereotypes and feelings. On the same token supplement companies are always jumping to provide "natural" supplements which may or may not be of any real use besides a waste of money. Its unfortunate that some might end up misusing remedies in the same way someone misuses drugs because of their lack of knowledge about the subject.
ReplyDeleteJulie
ReplyDeleteWhat a wonderful blog! I am a very big believer in herbal medicines. I find that some natural approaches to the common aliments are better than allopathic medicines. I have been using Aloe for burns, Peppermint for stomachaches. Clove for a toothache, Honey and Lemon for a soar thrat since I was a kid. It is great to be able to avoid the drug store when one of the kids have a soar throat, it's saves so much money and I know that they are not getting lots of sugar and unknown subsatnces from a cough drop. I rely on what my family has taught me when it comes to the appropriate measurements for consumption.
Even though as students in the Community Health program we have learned that everything is driven by money, others do not have the education or knowledge of this. I agree with what Julie said in having the approval of the FDA and how it doesn't mean a whole lot- to a certain extent. The FDA is not completely usless and people in our country really look to this stamp of approval when deciding what they will bring into their household. Some people only go by what the FDA says so maybe by them acknowledging that herbal rememdies do have some benefits and are safe it could open the doors for some new advancements in our health care system.- Christine Chambers
ReplyDeleteNatural supplements do sometimes give "natural" a bad rap. There are so many products out there that are labeled as natural, but are absolutely not, and would never be as beneficial as the natural plant-based products that Julie has written so knowingly about.
ReplyDeleteNice job on the blog!! In my opinion, I wouldn't go with a herbal medicine. I have never really been educated on this subject; but I still think it seems fishy. I just can't see myself eating a natural plant or drinking tea, and feeling better. I have always used the allopathic medicine and have not seen any effects on my health, so I don't see myself going elsewhere for medicine. I also agree with what shelby said, what is natural these days? And how can we trust a label that says natural? I feel like almost everything on this earth is tampered in someway and it is hard to trust, but this is something that I don's see myself being able to control.
ReplyDeleteWhen I was younger, an herbal treatments reference book, called "Back to Eden," caught my fancy, so I looked through it. I came across one herb blurb titled "coltsfoot." Someone had written "causes cancer" on that page. It bothered me to think of anybody who had used coltsfoot as a treatment, perhaps using that same reference book.
ReplyDeleteI want to believe that the old-fashioned, natural ways of doing things are better for you. In many ways, they are. I hope to find out more about natural medicine. Wish there was as much research as there is for pharmaceuticals...
We love your topic, Julie :)
So totally random and it made me think of this Blog but Last night while i was working my hands were beyond dry from washing and drying them a million times, I didnt have lotion though, so i used olive oil! it's a "herbal" remedy my grandmother always told me would work and it does quite well. just made me think of this blog again :) _ Heather Razin
ReplyDeleteI feel as if this is such an interesting topic, but something that a lot of people don't know much about. I wish that we could invest more time and money into finding out the benefits of using herbal medicines. If for the little things that go wrong, instead of going to the doctor to get some form of antibiotics is fine, but wouldn't it be cheaper and less time consuming if we had that knowledge about the simple things that we can do ourselves.
ReplyDeleteThis is a really interesting topic and I liked reading what everyone thought. I think that this is a very good alternative because it helps the whole person and not just the symptoms, plus it is all natural and would be better for everyone. I think many may be interested, but people dont know about it, and even if they did, it would be hard to learn what plant helps what. It would be alot of research and I bet many would rather go the easy route and take pills.
ReplyDeleteI think this is a viable alternative and may be a good remedy for some sicknesses, but harder for others.-- awesome blog topic
You guys are so right when you say that this approach is viable! It really is, but a problem with this could be what would happen to the homeopathic approach if research started being officially conducted. In other words, everything starts out as homeopathic or natural until a benefit of a plant, microorganism, or mold is discovered and then that particular beneficial aspect is isolated and synthesized for distribution. So, to keep things natural (completely) you can’t conduct expensive research, and without the research you don't really know what you’re ingesting. This is the ultimate catch 22!
ReplyDeleteDownload Video Player | Windows Media Player | Best Media Player
ReplyDeleteThanks for the always useful information. This is great information to help peoples and nice article written by writer. CnX Player is a powerful & efficient 4K ultra HD enabled video player for Windows 10 PC & Tablet, Android and iOS – iPhone & iPad.
ReplyDeleteDownload Media Player for Windows 10 - Microsoft Store
Download Video Player for Android from Google Play
Download Video Player for iPhone/iPad from Apple App Store